You are here

Marketing: the Hidden Disadvantages of Sustainability and CSR

Marketing: the Hidden Disadvantages of Sustainability and CSR
Published on
22 February 2018

Sustainability, environmentally-friendly products, policies for Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), all of these concepts are generally considered to be an added-value for companies. Yet recent research highlights the fact that these positive initiatives can sometimes backfire. What is the role of consumer perceptions when marketing a company’s sustainability and CSR policies?

The research

We speak with Sumitro Banerjee and Robert Mai, associate professors of marketing at Grenoble Ecole de Management (GEM). Sumitro shares with us results from his research on the topic of company decisions to invest in CSR versus product quality. Robert's research explored consumer perceptions of sustainable products, in particular the implicit view that sustainable products have lower strength (known as ELSI: Ethical = Less Strong Intuition).

CSR: mass market versus quality

"Everyone believes that CSR is a good idea. And research data shows that higher CSR leads to higher market value for firms. But questions remain: Why is market value higher because of increased CSR? How much should firms invest?" starts Sumitro. As product quality is a good indicator of R&D and previous investments, Sumitro investigated how much return on investment was provided by CSR versus product quality. "The interesting finding was that it's more important for firms with high-quality products to continue investing in quality, whereas mass market firms can get more bang for their buck by investing in CSR."

Two factors explain this finding: First, CSR is ultimately paid for by consumers and the company. Companies with lower quality products that target mass markets have greater economic incentive to invest in CSR because the costs and advantages of such policies are spread across a mass market. Second, Sumitro explains that consumers of high-end products who understand this tradeoff believe that CSR policies incur costs that could distract a company from maintaining the high quality of its products.

Sustainability: a deeply rooted negative image

Robert also looked at consumer perceptions, in particular their implicit and explicit views of sustainability: "In terms of health and sustainability, consumers generally make irrational decisions. If you ask them about their views on the matter, they will tend to prefer healthy and sustainable options. But in practice, they end up choosing the opposite!"

One of Robert's studies was carried out in a hospital. They provided people with two hand detergents (sustainable and conventional) and observed what people preferred. "We wanted to understand how behaviors change when their decisions are intuitive or observed (was the person being openly observed by the researcher or not). People who were openly watched by the researcher tended to pick the sustainable option 30% more often than the people we watched from a hidden viewpoint. Social expectations play a huge role in our decisions. Much like Sumitro's research on CSR, we found that the negative intuition concerning sustainability is particularly important when quality is valued (e.g., users value hand detergent in a hospital for its efficiency and quality)."

Robert goes on to explain: "Our research underlines the fact that the general populace holds a deeply rooted intuition that sustainable goods might be less strong, tasty or efficient. This has important implications for marketing because our natural reaction has been to highlight a product's sustainability. However, our findings illustrate that this approach may backfire, in particular with mass markets."

Understanding your market

The results provided by both researchers emphasize how important it is for companies to understand their market in terms of CSR and sustainability. Sumitro suggests: “For CSR investments, managers first need to evaluate customer perceptions of CSR and product quality. In particular, consider whether you’re serving a large or small segment of the market (mass merchandise versus high quality products). For smaller segments, it’s probably better to invest in quality and R&D. But for mass markets, it might be worthwhile to even prioritize CSR over quality or R&D.”

It is interesting to note that sustainability shares a similar fate: “When you’re marketing sustainable options, you have to be aware of the fact that while this can be very attractive to certain customers, it’s not the case for larger masses. In fact, chances are you will trigger a negative intuition,” adds Robert. As a result, the researcher suggests marketers play on aspects such as packaging, quality certificates and distribution channels to counteract negative intuitions about sustainable products. “For example, slogans that emphasize the relationship between sustainability and quality might help offset this negative intuition. Companies can also explore packaging options that reinforce a strong image through rich, dark colors and sturdier packaging materials.” The essential lesson to remember is that positive initiatives such as CSR and sustainability can backfire in terms of marketing. Each company has to find a balance that enables them to efficiently reach their target audience.

On the same subject

  • Alliances for the Environment
    Published on 15 January 2018

    Companies and Institutions: Creating Alliances for the Environment

    Environmental alliances between companies, institutions, NGOs and governments can provide several benefits for business. From customer relations to innovation or large-scale consortiums, alliances open the door to profitable collaborations.

  • Can TV Characters Teach Us About Management?
    Published on 14 September 2017

    Can TV Characters Teach Us About Management?

    From Mad Men to The Sopranos or The Walking Dead, discover the management wisdom of characters in popular TV series.

  • Circular Economy
    Published on 09 May 2017

    Troccauris: a Business Model for a Circular Economy?

    The circular economy relies on barter and re-using goods. Discover a flourishing example with Troccauris.

  • fornerino-marianela
    Published on 19 April 2017

    Sensory Marketing: Reinventing the Customer Experience

    How can images, sounds, smells, touch and taste impact a customer’s intention to purchase?

  • Published on 19 March 2017

    Easy-to-Read Food Labels Increase Intention to Purchase

    The battle for healthy food has become a worldwide concern. Public health agencies have invested energy and resources in fighting health risks such as obesity. In this battle, food labels that indicate nutritional facts have come to play a vital...

  • research on Contextual Television Advertising
    Published on 28 February 2017

    Research: Questioning the Effectiveness of Contextual Television Advertising

    As businesses and marketing go digital, companies have to track the effectiveness of their advertising across many channels. The growth of online transactions has made website conversions an essential factor for many businesses. Thanks to detailed...

  • Published on 24 February 2017

    Sulitest: the first international tool to assess Sustainability Literacy worldwide

    As of 2017, Grenoble Ecole de Management is making the Sulitest, the first international tool to assess Sustainability Literacy worldwide, compulsory for all of its staff, faculty and students. This is a further step in GEM’s journey to become a...

  • research on logo makeover perception
    Published on 18 October 2016

    Time for a Logo Makeover? Make it a Hit!

    A logo represents a brand’s image. It highlights its values and market position. Changing your logo can be a delicate transition. How can you ensure a smooth change? In January 2014, Grenoble Ecole de Management unveiled its new logo. Caroline Cuny...

  • Research: Creating Visitor Engagement Through Music
    Published on 29 February 2016

    Research: Creating Visitor Engagement Through Music

    Digital communications have created an information overload for customers. To stand out on the world wide web, companies have to offer clients a high-impact experience. When used properly, music provides a simple yet effective means of creating a...

  • Published on 13 October 2015

    Put Music on your Website

    Your web communication needs to offer a rich consumer experience to distinguish it from others. Nowadays, websites must evoke enjoyable and memorable feelings in their visitors in order to encourage them to revisit and recommend the website.

  • websites such as TripAdvisor have given consumers the power to impact a company's image.
    Published on 29 September 2015

    Customer reaction and Market identity

    This article, written by Tao Wang, Filippo Carlo Wezel and Bernard Forgues, examines the conditions under which organizations publicly respond to unfavorable consumer evaluations that challenge their market identity. This study relies on an analyse...

  • Published on 22 June 2015

    Research: Microeconomic Degrowth, Community Supported Agriculture

    Economic growth is the cornerstone of mainstream macroeconomics. In the face of economic crises and unemployment, growth has long been the only acceptable solution. Yet many issues have started to challenge this dominant economic model. As a result...

  • Published on 16 January 2015

    Nostalgia makes consumers more likely to spend or donate money

    The use of nostalgia has been a top trend in marketing in the last few years, in commercials, product lines and even TV shows. The present study demonstrates that feeling nostalgic weakens the desire to hold on to money, and makes it easier to part...